At Franco’s, we don’t believe in one-size-fits-all pizza. With a massive selection of sauces, cheeses, proteins, veggies, and finishing drizzles, our online ordering system lets you build something completely custom—every single time.

We’re talking garlic sauce with steak and feta. Tzatziki with grilled chicken and olives. Hot honey, cheddar, jalapeños, and pineapple? Absolutely. The combinations you can build are nearly endless—and yes, they’re all just a few clicks away.

But with that many options, it’s easy to get stuck wondering, “Where do I even start?”

So Many Toppings, You Might Need a Little Help Deciding

That’s where our Not-So-Secret Menu comes in.

Here’s a look at the unique combinations you can build when you order from Franco’s online. Each pizza is fully customizable by size and toppings, and you can make adjustments as you like. Use this guide to build your dream pizza next time you order.

One more thing: Since these are custom creations, they’re only available online. To keep things clear and get your pizza made exactly the way it should be, just head to our online ordering platform to build your favorite Not-So-Secret combo.

Check out our No-So-Secret Online Only Menu

1. Taco & Ranch

Can’t decide between a taco and a pizza? Get both by creating this secret menu item onlineAT!

Base: Taco Pizza Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Taco Beef Topping, Bacon

Veggies: Black Olive, Jalapeño, Tomato

Drizzle: Ranch Dressing

2. Steak & Spinach

Our garlic sauce is a sleeper hit! Have you tried it yet? This combination of garlic with steak, feta, spinach, and onion is sure to please. 

Base: Garlic Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Protein: Steak Topping

Veggies: Spinach Topping, Red Onion

3. Pickled Bacon

If you’re a pickle lover but you want plenty of protein, try this pizza packed with flavor and everything you love, including bacon and grilled chicken. 

Base: Ranch Dressing Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Protein: Bacon, Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Pickles, Banana Peppers

4. Classic Margherita Twist

Rather than using our classic red sauce, this pizza has a twist: our garlic sauce base is used in harmony with parmesan and tomato for a delicious result. 

Base: Garlic Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Veggies: Tomato, Spinach Topping

5. Hot Cherry Explosion

Experience a culinary explosion with the powerful flavors of our wing sauce, parmesan, hot cherry peppers, and more! 

Base: Wing Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Protein: Grilled Chicken, Pepperoni

Veggies: Hot Cherry Peppers, Roasted Sweet Peppers

6. Loaded Tzatziki

Tzatziki lovers, rejoice! Get everything you love about a Greek salad in pizza form (the best form). This pizza is truly loaded with all your favorites.

Base: Tzatziki Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Protein: Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Spinach Topping, Green Olive, Tomato

7. Sweet & Spicy Veggie

Here’s a pizza for the adventurous vegetarian! Our hot honey sauce base and hot honey drizzle elevate all the veggies (and fruit) on this pizza. 

Base: Hot Honey Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Veggies: Pineapple, Jalapeño, Roasted Sweet Peppers

Drizzle: Hot Honey Drizzle

8. Spicy Steak Supreme

What’s better than steak on a pizza? Steak and sausage on a pizza! Get an extra kick from the jalapeño, and don’t forget the signature Franco’s steak sauce for the base for the tastiest steak pizza you’ve ever tried. 

Base: Franco’s Steak Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Protein: Steak Topping, Sausage

Veggies: Jalapeño, Red Onion

9. Veggie Lovers Ranch

If you love salads and especially love croutons, try the veggie lovers ranch pizza! Our veggie lovers ranch pizza is basically a salad on a delicious pizza crust.

Base: Ranch Dressing Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Veggies: Mushroom, Spinach Topping, Roasted Sweet Peppers, Black Olive

10. Honey Pepperoni Blaze

The spice of the pepperoni and the saltiness of the bacon contrast perfectly with our hot honey sauce base to make this pizza a fan favorite. 

Base: Hot Honey Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Pepperoni, Bacon

Veggies: Jalapeño, Red Onion

11. Mediterranean Delight

Our Mediterranean delight pizza differs from our loaded tzatziki pizza in one important way: it has black olives instead of green! We understand just how different these two olives are, so we offer each combination to our customers. 

Base: Tzatziki Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Protein: Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Tomato, Spinach Topping, Black Olive

12. Sweet BBQ Sausage

This pizza is all about the BBQ! And what goes better with BBQ than sausage and bacon? 

Base: BBQ Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Sausage, Bacon

Veggies: Pineapple, Roasted Sweet Peppers

13. Hot Island Fusion

Pineapple on a pizza may be a contentious choice, but that’s why it’s on our not-so-secret menu! Franco’s won’t yuck your yum, so order our hot island fusion pizza if that’s what you’re in the mood for. 

Base: Hot Honey Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Ham

Veggies: Pineapple, Banana Peppers

14. Greek BBQ

This combination may surprise you, but our BBQ sauce base pairs well with the Greek feta cheese and olives of this pizza. 

Base: BBQ Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Protein: Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Green Olive, Spinach Topping

15. Ranch Buffalo Crunch

Here in Buffalo, we may praise blue cheese and Buffalo sauce, but there’s room in the not-so-secret menu for ranch lovers to indulge. Take a walk on the wild side and enjoy this forbidden combination of ranch, wing sauce, and chicken finger topping. 

Base: Wing Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella 

Protein: Chicken Finger Topping

Veggies: Banana Peppers, Red Onion

Drizzle: Ranch Dressing

16. Spicy Garlic Paradise

You don’t have to choose just one cheese, protein, or veggie when you order our spicy garlic paradise pizza – this pie comes with two of each. 

Base: Garlic Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Protein: Sausage, Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Jalapeño, Hot Cherry Peppers

17. Pickle Ranch Supreme

Whether you’re a pickle fan or you want a burger in pizza form, this is the pizza for you! 

Base: Ranch Dressing Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and American

Protein: Hamburger Beef

Veggies: Pickles, Tomato

18. BBQ Veggie

Vegetarians love our BBQ veggie pizza! The sweetness of the BBQ sauce and roasted sweet peppers contrasts perfectly with our herby ranch and creamy mozzarella. 

Base: BBQ Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella

Veggies: Mushroom, Roasted Sweet Peppers, Red Onion

Drizzle: Ranch Dressing

19. Cherry Honey Sizzle

If you like our hot honey sauce base, you’ll love this pie. This pizza features our flavorful sausage along with the hot cherry peppers and zingy banana peppers. 

Base: Hot Honey Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Protein: Sausage

Veggies: Hot Cherry Peppers, Banana Peppers

20. Loaded Steakhouse

Franco’s steak sauce is the perfect base for this pizza that’s loaded with grilled chicken, mushrooms, red onion, and steak (of course). 

Base: Franco’s Steak Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Parmesan

Protein: Steak Topping, Grilled Chicken

Veggies: Mushroom, Red Onion

21. Loaded Spinach

Our loaded spinach pizza combines our delicious garlic sauce base with salty feta, sharp parmesan, and all of the veggies that pair best with these flavors. 

Base: Garlic Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella, Feta, and Parmesan

Veggies: Spinach Topping, Tomato, Mushroom, Black Olive

22. Mediterranean Veggie

The Mediterranean veggie pizza is the vegetarian version of our Mediterranean delight pizza. Ditch the grilled chicken but enjoy all the other flavors of this customer favorite. 

Base: Tzatziki Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella and Feta

Veggies: Spinach Topping, Tomato, Green Olive, Black Olive

23. Steak & Blue

If you like the idea of our spicy steak supreme pizza but don’t want the jalapeños, this pizza is a great alternative! 

Base: Franco’s Steak Sauce

Cheese: Mozzarella

Protein: Steak Topping

Veggies: Red Onion, Mushroom

Drizzle: Blue Cheese Drizzle

24. The Hot Honey Inferno

Set your mouth ablaze with this fiery combination: hot honey sauce base, jalapeños, and hot cherry peppers, oh my!  

Base: Hot Honey Sauce Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Sausage, Pepperoni

Veggies: Jalapeño, Hot Cherry Peppers

25. Sizzling Steakhouse

Enjoy all the flavors you’d want at a steakhouse by ordering this specialty pizza from Franco’s. Our steak topping goes perfectly with mushroom and jalapeño! 

Base: Ranch Dressing Base

Cheese: Mozzarella and Cheddar

Protein: Steak Topping, Bacon

Veggies: Mushroom, Jalapeño

Ready to Order?

Whether you’re in the mood for something bold, spicy, sweet, or savory, there’s a custom combination waiting for you at Franco’s. Remember, these unique pizzas are only available through online ordering—so head to our website to start building your own Not-So-Secret favorite.

If you’re new to Franco’s, check our guide to learn more about how to customize and enjoy the best Buffalo-style pizza you’ve ever tasted.

We’ve been proudly serving the Buffalo community since 1978, and we’re always evolving to meet the tastes of our loyal customers. So next time you’re ordering online, skip the basic pepperoni and go bold with one of our must-try combos.

Tried a Not-So-Secret combo or your own custom creation and loved it? Share your thoughts or photos with us on social media. We love hearing what our fans are cooking up.